When you’re planning a celebration—whether it’s a milestone birthday, a baby shower, or a family gathering—the cake is more than dessert. It’s the centerpiece, the moment everyone gathers around with their cameras, the sweet ending that leaves a lasting impression. With so many styles, flavors, and designs available, picking the right cake can feel a bit overwhelming. But with a few simple tips, you can find the perfect custom cake to make your special day truly unforgettable.

Start With the Occasion and Your Personal Style

Think about what you’re celebrating and who you’re celebrating with. A wedding anniversary might call for a classic multi-tiered cake, while a child’s birthday could be the perfect opportunity for a playful number or letter cake. For something intimate and charming, vintage heart cakes add a nostalgic touch. The key is to choose a design that resonates with the vibe of your event. Remember, a great cake reflects your personality and the spirit of the day—it’s not just about following trends.

Consider Portions and Practicality

The size and shape of your cake often depend on how many people you’ll be serving and how you’d like to present it. For larger groups, a tiered cake ensures you’ll have enough for everyone, while still making a showstopping centerpiece. For smaller, more casual gatherings, simpler designs—like cupcakes, cake pops, or cakesicles—might make serving easier. Even pairing a single-tier cake with a variety of decorated sugar cookies or chocolate-covered strawberries can create a dessert spread that feels personal and thoughtful.

Flavors That Speak to You

Flavors shouldn’t be an afterthought. Sure, a cake that looks beautiful is wonderful, but the taste is what keeps guests talking long after the event. Consider what you and your guests truly enjoy. Classic vanilla or chocolate are always reliable, but unique options—like a moist, creamy tres leches cake—can bring an extra layer of excitement. If you’re nostalgic for childhood treats, decorated sugar cookies or chocolate-covered pretzels can add a familiar, comforting flavor to your table.

Timing Is Everything

When it comes to custom desserts, giving yourself plenty of lead time is crucial. This ensures your baker can accommodate special designs, unique flavor requests, or any additional details you have in mind. Plus, the earlier you reach out, the more flexibility you’ll have to adjust or refine your ideas.

Extras That Elevate the Experience

Sometimes, it’s the little extras that make a dessert table memorable. Cake pops, party shooters, or chocolate-covered Oreos can complement your main cake beautifully. Not only do these smaller treats offer variety, but they’re also a hit for guests who prefer a small sweet bite over a full slice of cake. Consider including a mix of options to make everyone feel catered to.

In the End, It’s About Celebrating Together

Choosing a cake isn’t just about finding something delicious—it’s about creating a moment that brings people together. With a thoughtful approach to design, flavor, and size, you can create a centerpiece that feels special, tastes incredible, and reflects the joy of the day. The right custom cake is more than a dessert—it’s a memory waiting to be shared.